Debate surfaces about executives diagnosed with cancer
Posted Jul 31st 2006 8:00AM by Jacki Donaldson
Filed under: Breast Cancer, Prevention, All Cancers, Daily news
Dealing with cancer in private is hard. Dealing with cancer publicly can be even harder. CEO Donna McAleer -- the founding executive and public face of the large, growing health care company Elant -- knows this firsthand. She just recently went public with her breast cancer diagnosis and prognosis after rumors of her demise started circulating. McAleer set the record straight, announcing that she is doing just fine. While her experience has been frightening, she is surviving well -- and she wants the public to know. She has run Elant for 20 years and wants to dispel any myths about its stability. Apple CEO Steve Jobs faced the same public drama in 2004 after surgery for pancreatic cancer and subsequent drops in Apple stock. Jobs recovered -- and so did the stock -- but the speculation that swirled was powerful and potentially damaging. Just as it was that same year when Kraft Foods was criticized for withholding details of its CEO's hospitalization.
There is some debate in the business world about all of this -- about whether or not executive illnesses should be disclosed. For public companies, one opinion is that there is an obligation to respond quickly to the public. In a private company, it's up to the CEO. McAleer's Elant is not a publicly traded company and there is no worry about stock price -- but her decision to reveal her personal health crisis was the right thing to do, she says. "I have an obligation to share this news in how I progress, in order to educate and make sure people aren't frightened by it," she said in reference to the memo she sent to her 700 employees and community groups too.
I'm open and honest about my own cancer experience because I believe it can help others -- and it helps me to talk about it too. So I'm a fan of a forthcoming approach in the workplace. I appreciate that some fear repercussions that might result from such a disclosure. But honesty may be the best policy -- for prevention of rumors and addressing worry and raising awareness too. McAleer seems to agree as she takes this opportunity to speak up, to encourage women to seek mammograms and to follow up on them.
Tags: announcing, Apple, approach, awareness, best, breast, business, cancer, care, CEO, circulating, community, companies, company, criticized, damaging, debate, demise, details, diagnosis, disclosed, dispel, Donna, drama, drops, educate, Elant, employees, encourage, executive, face, fan, fear, fine, foods, forthcoming, founding, frightening, groups, hard, harder, health, honesty, hospitalization, Jobs, Kraft, mammograms, McAleer, memo, myths, obligation, pancreatic, policy, powerful, prevention, private, prognosis, public, publicly, record, right, rumors, set, speak, speculation, stability, Steve, stock, straight, surgery, survivor, swirled, thing, withholding, workplace, world, worry